There are no markers for this video.
00:00:00Support
00:00:00for the Statehouse News Bureau
00:00:02comes from Medical Mutual,
00:00:03dedicated to the health
00:00:03and well-being of Ohioans,
00:00:05offering health insurance
00:00:05plans, as well as dental,
00:00:08vision and wellness programs
00:00:08to help people
00:00:10achieve their goals
00:00:10and remain healthy.
00:00:12More at Med mutual.com.
00:00:14The law offices of Porter,
00:00:14right, Morris and Arthur LLP.
00:00:17Porter Wright is dedicated
00:00:17to bringing inspired legal
00:00:21outcomes to the Ohio business
00:00:21community.
00:00:23More at porterwright.com.
00:00:25Porter Wright
00:00:25inspired Every day
00:00:27in Ohio Education Association,
00:00:27representing 120,000
00:00:31educators who are united
00:00:31in their mission
00:00:33to create the excellent
00:00:33public schools.
00:00:35Every child deserves
00:00:35more at OHEA.org.
00:00:38House Minority Leader Allison
00:00:38Russo is leaving as leader.
00:00:42State Democrats
00:00:42will choose their next chair.
00:00:45And breaking down the Senate
00:00:45budget.
00:00:48All this
00:00:48weekend, the state of Ohio.
00:01:09Welcome to the state of Ohio.
00:01:11I'm Sara Donaldson, in
00:01:11for Karen Kasler.
00:01:14Ohio Senate
00:01:15lawmakers unveiled
00:01:16hundreds of amendments
00:01:16this week
00:01:17to the biennial state budget.
00:01:19Senate Finance
00:01:20Committee members
00:01:20tell me they came
00:01:21from thousands
00:01:21of submitted amendments.
00:01:24Among the biggest changes
00:01:24to the bill
00:01:25the House sent over
00:01:25two months ago
00:01:27are a long debated income
00:01:27tax cut
00:01:29and what is now
00:01:31the third iteration
00:01:31of a framework
00:01:33to fund stadium construction
00:01:33in suburban Cleveland.
00:01:36There are shifts in
00:01:36K-through-12 public school
00:01:38funding plans and property
00:01:38tax proposals and much more.
00:01:43I sit down with Senate
00:01:43Finance Chair Jerry Serino
00:01:46later on in the show
00:01:46to break down the basics.
00:01:49But first, Ohio House
00:01:49Minority Leader Allison Russo
00:01:52is leaving her post, leading
00:01:52the Democratic Party's caucus.
00:01:56Her colleagues first elected
00:01:56her to that role in 2022.
00:02:00our caucus rules dictate,
00:02:00you know, that
00:02:03if you do decide to run
00:02:03for another office,
00:02:06that you step down.
00:02:07And I haven't made a decision
00:02:07about that yet.
00:02:10But I also know,
00:02:10you know, as a strong leader
00:02:12in the importance of smooth
00:02:12and organized transitions,
00:02:16I start at the beginning
00:02:16of the General Assembly
00:02:18and said to my members
00:02:18that wanted to get us
00:02:20through the budget process,
00:02:22we're coming up
00:02:22to the end of that process.
00:02:25And so it's time
00:02:25to make that transition,
00:02:27to give a new leadership team,
00:02:29time to get organized
00:02:30for the next part
00:02:30of the General Assembly,
00:02:33after the summer break.
00:02:34And, to prepare
00:02:35for the 2026 election cycle,
00:02:35to grow our caucus.
00:02:39Russo led the caucus
00:02:39through a brutal battle over
00:02:42legislative redistricting.
00:02:44She's not leaving
00:02:44the legislature.
00:02:46She says she's going to stay
00:02:46in her House
00:02:48seat through the end of this
00:02:48general
00:02:49Assembly in 2026,
00:02:49when she hits her term limit.
00:02:53Russo has not yet said
00:02:53what her next move is, though
00:02:56she's long been considered
00:02:56among potential candidates
00:02:59for Democratic federal
00:02:59or state wide public office.
00:03:02In May, she said her time
00:03:02serving may not be over.
00:03:06I don't think that my time
00:03:06in public service is done.
00:03:08But I have not made
00:03:08a decision
00:03:11about what that means
00:03:11for 2026.
00:03:13House Democrats have not yet
00:03:13set the date to vote on
00:03:16and fill the vacancy,
00:03:17although the caucus
00:03:17usually votes
00:03:19first behind closed doors
00:03:21and then the House holds
00:03:21a full floor vote.
00:03:23Both will likely come
00:03:23before the end of the month.
00:03:27And the Ohio Democratic
00:03:27Party needs a new chair.
00:03:30Its executive committee
00:03:30is scheduled
00:03:31to select
00:03:31that person this coming week,
00:03:33and more than one candidate
00:03:33has said
00:03:35they want to take over
00:03:35for outgoing chair
00:03:37Liz Walters, who has been
00:03:37at its helm since 2021.
00:03:41Walters is leaving to become
00:03:41chief executive of Target
00:03:44Smart, a democratic data
00:03:44and analytics firm.
00:03:47Democrats have weathered
00:03:47back to back
00:03:50bruising election cycles
00:03:50on the statewide ticket.
00:03:53Among the frontrunners
00:03:53for chair is former state
00:03:55lawmaker Kathleen Clyde,
00:03:55who already clinched
00:03:58a key endorsement in her bid
00:03:58to be the party's chair,
00:04:01that of former U.S.
00:04:02Senator Sherrod Brown.
00:04:04Clyde
00:04:04says her unsuccessful run
00:04:06for secretary of state
00:04:07in 2018 prepares
00:04:07her most for this role.
00:04:11I learned about developing
00:04:11a compelling message
00:04:14and breaking through and,
00:04:14crowded ballot as a down
00:04:17ballot candidate.
00:04:19And perhaps most importantly,
00:04:19in a way, for this, office
00:04:23that I'm seeking, I broke
00:04:23a record for fundraising.
00:04:27I was the raise
00:04:27the most money, than any
00:04:31Democratic secretary of state
00:04:31candidate had ever raised.
00:04:34When I ran
00:04:34for secretary of state
00:04:36and being able to raise
00:04:36those resources,
00:04:39connect with donors in state
00:04:39and nationally is going
00:04:43to be critically important
00:04:44to have a well-funded Ohio
00:04:44Democratic Party.
00:04:48Stow City Council member Kyle
00:04:48Herman worked in President
00:04:51Obama's administration
00:04:51and then for the
00:04:53National Democratic Institute.
00:04:55Since coming back to Ohio
00:04:55in 2020, Herman has also been
00:04:58an advocate
00:04:58for ranked choice voting.
00:05:01He says he's running
00:05:01on his diverse background
00:05:03in international, national,
00:05:03state and local affairs.
00:05:07levels.
00:05:07I'm not part of the party
00:05:07insiders old boys club.
00:05:10I'm coming to this
00:05:10from the perspective of
00:05:13I thought my career
00:05:13was going to be
00:05:14about advancing democracy
00:05:14in the Middle East.
00:05:17I was working on democracy
00:05:19programs in Iraq and Lebanon,
00:05:19raising millions of dollars
00:05:22in competitive grants
00:05:23to try to democratize
00:05:23those countries.
00:05:25And I realized after 2020
00:05:25that we need to democratize
00:05:30Ohio as well,
00:05:32the level of tribalism
00:05:32and corruption
00:05:34and polarization
00:05:34that we have in our state.
00:05:36None of the issues
00:05:36we care about
00:05:37are going to get solved
00:05:37unless we fix democracy first.
00:05:40And I want to make sure
00:05:40that the Democratic Party
00:05:40leaders understand that
00:05:43and aren't trying
00:05:43to just treat this as another,
00:05:47transactional coronation
00:05:47for who within their party
00:05:50is going to be in charge.
00:05:51We need to have serious
00:05:51conversations as a party
00:05:54about how do we empower
00:05:54all Ada County chairs
00:05:57to lead at the local level
00:05:59And Tammy Wilson,
00:05:59who has mounted
00:06:00two unsuccessful
00:06:00congressional bids
00:06:03against Republican
00:06:03Representative Jim
00:06:05Jordan, is also in the race
00:06:05for chair.
00:06:07She says she believes
00:06:07the Democrats need
00:06:09to focus on strengthening
00:06:09their infrastructure
00:06:12statewide
00:06:12and clarifying their message.
00:06:14It was a more crowded field
00:06:14before Thursday evening.
00:06:17Former Ohio Democratic Party
00:06:19executive director and current
00:06:19state Senator Bill Dimora
00:06:22threw his hat in the ring
00:06:22early on
00:06:24but has since bowed out,
00:06:24saying
00:06:25he didn't have the votes
00:06:25to win.
00:06:28Greene County Democratic Party
00:06:29Chairwoman Kim McCarthy exited
00:06:29shortly after dimora.
00:06:33Whoever wins will be guiding
00:06:33a political party that hasn't
00:06:36won a governor's race
00:06:36since 2006 statewide.
00:06:39The party's presence
00:06:39is dwindling with U.S.
00:06:42Senator Bernie Marino's defeat
00:06:42of Sherrod Brown last year.
00:06:45Democrats hold only one
00:06:45elected office statewide,
00:06:49a seat on the state's
00:06:49highest court.
00:06:51And Ohio Supreme Court
00:06:52Justice Jennifer Brunner
00:06:52is up for reelection in 2026.
00:06:57State lawmakers
00:06:57have less than a month
00:06:59to finish the state budget,
00:06:59which governor
00:07:01Mike DeWine
00:07:01must sign by June 30th.
00:07:03We sat down with the Senate
00:07:03finance chair
00:07:06to discuss the latest
00:07:06draft released this week.
00:07:09the Senate's version
00:07:10of the budget totals
00:07:10more than 5500 pages.
00:07:13Perhaps the most defining
00:07:13part, though, is a measure
00:07:15that would flatten the state
00:07:15income tax.
00:07:17Your caucus has proposed
00:07:17transitioning down
00:07:19from the current
00:07:19two bracket system
00:07:21to a flat rate for everybody,
00:07:21at 2.75% by tax year 2026,
00:07:26I should say everybody
00:07:26making under $26,000 a year.
00:07:30Why and why now?
00:07:32Well, it would be over 26,000
00:07:32because
00:07:35up to 26,000.
00:07:36There are no taxes. Certainly.
00:07:38So, look, this is, should
00:07:38not be a surprise to anybody.
00:07:42The the General Assembly,
00:07:42our caucus in both the House
00:07:47and in the Senate, have been
00:07:47reducing the brackets,
00:07:50reducing the rates
00:07:50for over ten years now.
00:07:53And remember, the income tax
00:07:53was established in 1972.
00:07:58So Ohio existed
00:07:59for a very long time
00:07:59without a state income tax.
00:08:02And it doesn't mean that we,
00:08:03you know,
00:08:04we don't have to have it
00:08:05in perpetuity
00:08:05and continue it,
00:08:07the way it's
00:08:07currently structured.
00:08:09Look, the idea is that
00:08:09we want to support
00:08:12economic growth
00:08:12in the state of Ohio
00:08:15and everything we do
00:08:15is, is to promote that,
00:08:18because unless we have strong,
00:08:18vibrant, growing economy,
00:08:22we can't do the things that
00:08:22we need to do to help people,
00:08:25in their safety net programs,
00:08:25to be able to support them
00:08:28if we don't have
00:08:28the means to do it.
00:08:30We can't do it
00:08:30to the same extent that we
00:08:32we think we need to.
00:08:34So this is about
00:08:35putting money back
00:08:35in the hands of taxpayers,
00:08:38who will take the money
00:08:38and spend the money?
00:08:41And that has a
00:08:41multiplier effect on the state
00:08:41of Ohio's economy.
00:08:45And so we're excited about it.
00:08:46We think it's the fair
00:08:46thing to do.
00:08:47Will be joining 14
00:08:47other states
00:08:50that have a flat tax.
00:08:52It makes taxation
00:08:52more predictable, easier to,
00:08:56to deal with.
00:08:56Easier to project what your
00:08:56liabilities are going to be.
00:09:00We think it's
00:09:00a very net positive
00:09:00for the state of Ohio.
00:09:02Sure.
00:09:03So right now,
00:09:04this would most immediately
00:09:04affect Ohioans
00:09:06who make just over six figures
00:09:08or anything over six figures,
00:09:08if it goes into effect,
00:09:11saving them and costing
00:09:11Ohio more than $1.6
00:09:14billion over this biennium,
00:09:14according
00:09:16to the Legislative Service
00:09:16Commission.
00:09:18Now, you mentioned high
00:09:18earners
00:09:19might reinvest their money
00:09:19back into the state.
00:09:22One senator tells me
00:09:22they were asked to be modest
00:09:24in their budget amendments
00:09:24to account for,
00:09:27you know, a tax cut like this.
00:09:29What kind of cuts did
00:09:29you have to make from GRF
00:09:32funding
00:09:32to make way for a flat tax?
00:09:33Well, we had in
00:09:34both the House version,
00:09:34they had it in their budget
00:09:38and we had it in ours.
00:09:39There's lots of earmarks,
00:09:39lots of requests
00:09:40for special projects,
00:09:40community projects, etc..
00:09:44And, last year
00:09:44we did the gift budget,
00:09:48where the House and Senate
00:09:48together spent for community
00:09:52type projects, $730
00:09:52million less than a year ago.
00:09:57So this time around,
00:09:57we asked our caucus to
00:10:00to be more deliberate
00:10:00in what they were asking for.
00:10:04When we went through
00:10:04and rationalized our budget,
00:10:07prior to the sub
00:10:07bill being introduced,
00:10:09you know, we took a very dim
00:10:09view of adding lots
00:10:12and lots of things
00:10:12that every member wanted to.
00:10:14We wanted to have,
00:10:15because we felt
00:10:17it was a proper tradeoff
00:10:17to make
00:10:19so that we could lower
00:10:19the tax rates
00:10:20and do other things
00:10:20that are in the budget.
00:10:22Also, housing
00:10:22and other places
00:10:26that we can't do everything.
00:10:28We have a fixed
00:10:29amount of money
00:10:29that we have to, to spend
00:10:31and we have to balance
00:10:31the budget, of course.
00:10:33So we felt
00:10:33it was worth it to, to, to,
00:10:37diminish the number
00:10:37of special earmark projects
00:10:41in both the House
00:10:41and the Senate
00:10:43in order to be able to do
00:10:44these bold, grand things that
00:10:44we think are good for Ohio.
00:10:48Now, shifting gears a bit,
00:10:49and this may be the most
00:10:49watched part of this budget,
00:10:53the Senate got rid
00:10:53of the House's debt
00:10:54and bond structure
00:10:55to fund a requested package
00:10:55of $600 million,
00:10:58so the owners of the Cleveland
00:10:58Browns,
00:11:00the Haslam family,
00:11:01could build a domed stadium
00:11:01and a surrounding
00:11:03economic project in suburban
00:11:03Brook Park.
00:11:06So instead,
00:11:07your caucus
00:11:08has created a performance
00:11:08grant program
00:11:10funded by a percentage
00:11:10of money, $1.7 billion.
00:11:13I believe it would be
00:11:13600,600,000,000
00:11:17for the Browns.
00:11:17Millions and billions.
00:11:19And then,
00:11:20you know, more money
00:11:20for potential future projects.
00:11:23That money is coming from cash
00:11:23managed by the Department
00:11:26of Commerce's
00:11:26Division of Unclaimed Funds.
00:11:28So how did you land on this
00:11:28proposal?
00:11:31Well, we were, first of all
00:11:31to get the governor.
00:11:34The House
00:11:35and the Senate
00:11:36have all agreed individually
00:11:37and under
00:11:37some different circumstance,
00:11:39is that this project in Brook
00:11:39Park to develop
00:11:42not just the stadium,
00:11:42but mixed use
00:11:44development as well,
00:11:44in an area of Cleveland.
00:11:47And I'm a native Clevelander,
00:11:47so, I know a little bit
00:11:50about Cleveland there
00:11:50in Northeast Ohio,
00:11:53that is kind of an economic
00:11:53dead zone right now.
00:11:55So it needs to be turned
00:11:55into something
00:11:57that's productive
00:11:58for the state, for the city,
00:11:58and for the county.
00:12:00So we like the project.
00:12:02We think it's a good economic
00:12:02development project.
00:12:04The question was the House,
00:12:04the governor in the Senate
00:12:07had different views on how to,
00:12:07help finance that activity.
00:12:11So we don't like
00:12:11I personally don't like
00:12:14the idea of floating bonds.
00:12:16The interest over 25
00:12:16years of a bond offering
00:12:20would be in excess of $400
00:12:20million.
00:12:23That would come out
00:12:23of the General Revenue Fund.
00:12:26I don't like that.
00:12:29And and there would be
00:12:29additional, legal costs
00:12:31and so on.
00:12:32Could be another 10
00:12:32or $20 million
00:12:34when you do a bond
00:12:34offering that big.
00:12:36So we were searching
00:12:36for different ways
00:12:38to do this without also,
00:12:38as the governor had proposed,
00:12:41raising taxes, doubling
00:12:41the taxes on gambling.
00:12:44Okay.
00:12:45Our caucus really
00:12:46doesn't like to raise taxes,
00:12:47except in
00:12:47very unique circumstances.
00:12:50So we looked at
00:12:50how could we do a cash deal
00:12:52that's really
00:12:52what it all came down to.
00:12:55And I was aware
00:12:57we were aware in the Senate
00:12:57of the unclaimed funds number.
00:12:59Right now, the up to date
00:12:59number is about 4.3
00:13:03billion
00:13:03sitting in unclaimed funds.
00:13:06It's what I call lazy money
00:13:06because it's not really
00:13:08being used to
00:13:09to do anything else other than
00:13:09gain some modest interest.
00:13:13That is accumulating.
00:13:15So we looked at that
00:13:15and we said,
00:13:16okay, you know,
00:13:16can we tap into that?
00:13:20By the way,
00:13:20the the the legislature
00:13:22in the administration's
00:13:22in the past have,
00:13:25borrowed money
00:13:25from the unclaimed funds,
00:13:28for certain emergency
00:13:28situations. Okay.
00:13:30So this is not
00:13:30without precedent.
00:13:32I think it has happened
00:13:32about 15 or 16 times.
00:13:36Other states do this as well.
00:13:38And our goal here is to, to
00:13:38to use this,
00:13:41this cash in a way
00:13:41that's going to produce,
00:13:44you know, a multiplier effect
00:13:44of other economic,
00:13:47advantages for the state
00:13:47and for the region,
00:13:50where this is located.
00:13:51So we took a look at that
00:13:51and we said, okay,
00:13:54we would like to negotiate
00:13:54an arrangement
00:13:57with the Browns,
00:13:57with the Haslam family,
00:13:59so that we could deliver
00:13:59$600 million for this project
00:14:03on top of the 1.2,
00:14:04that billion that the Hassam
00:14:04family is putting in.
00:14:08Right.
00:14:10And and try to
00:14:10make this, this deal happen,
00:14:13and we set it up
00:14:13as a performance grant.
00:14:15The performance
00:14:16grant basically is lays out
00:14:16over a 16 year period,
00:14:20that in, in
00:14:20if you can imagine
00:14:23some columns here,
00:14:23one through 16 for the years.
00:14:27And then we have a projection
00:14:27of incremental taxes
00:14:31that are going to come
00:14:32into the state,
00:14:32as a result of this project.
00:14:35In the beginning,
00:14:36it would be largely
00:14:36payroll taxes
00:14:39that would come in
00:14:39or income tax,
00:14:41because of the construction,
00:14:41phase of the, of the stadium
00:14:45once they start having games
00:14:45and parking and other things.
00:14:48So there will be sales tax,
00:14:48there will be income tax,
00:14:51there will be, commercial
00:14:51activity taxes
00:14:54all coming into the state.
00:14:56It will be verified
00:14:56as incremental.
00:14:58So we're not double counting
00:14:59money
00:14:59that the Browns are already
00:15:01generating for the state
00:15:02in Cleveland
00:15:02at their current site.
00:15:06And our plan
00:15:06is over the 16 year period
00:15:08that we will get back
00:15:08in incremental taxes
00:15:11to 600 million
00:15:11plus another about 36 million,
00:15:15because we have an inflator
00:15:15in the targets for each year.
00:15:18To protect the state
00:15:18even further,
00:15:21we have four true up
00:15:21periods scheduled in this
00:15:2516 year arrangement.
00:15:26So at each four year
00:15:26true up period,
00:15:29we would sit down and look at,
00:15:29okay,
00:15:31what are the actual
00:15:31incremental taxes
00:15:33that have come in
00:15:34and how does that compare
00:15:34to the forecast?
00:15:37And if there are any negative
00:15:39gaps in between those numbers,
00:15:41at the end of each
00:15:41of the four year periods,
00:15:43the Browns are putting
00:15:43in a $50 million,
00:15:46escrow account in place
00:15:46that we will control,
00:15:50that we will be able to tap
00:15:50into and cover the differences
00:15:54should they exist
00:15:55in any of those four year,
00:15:55two up periods.
00:15:58If during the course of the,
00:15:59let's say,
00:15:59the next, eight years,
00:16:02when we do the true ups,
00:16:02if they are short again
00:16:05and we've already used
00:16:05the first 50 million escrow,
00:16:09they have a line of credit
00:16:10that will be established
00:16:10for another 50 million that we
00:16:13will be able to tap into.
00:16:15So we think we
00:16:15have $100 million of, of
00:16:15surety basically set up
00:16:19to make sure that
00:16:19if there are any shortfalls
00:16:21in the actual
00:16:23incremental taxes produced,
00:16:24that we will have coverage
00:16:24for that.
00:16:26And I want to shift
00:16:27gears here, because there's
00:16:28so much in the budget
00:16:28to talk about.
00:16:30But just a quick follow up.
00:16:31You know,
00:16:32you mentioned it's
00:16:32not unprecedented to tap
00:16:35into these unclaimed funds,
00:16:35but what do you say to folks
00:16:38who might argue it's
00:16:38not the state's money to claim
00:16:41these assets are coming
00:16:41from dormant bank accounts or,
00:16:44you know, uncashed
00:16:44checks of Ohioans?
00:16:46Yeah.
00:16:46Well,
00:16:47and this is an
00:16:47I'll get into the the
00:16:49legal concept of a shipment,
00:16:50which I think most people are
00:16:50probably not familiar with.
00:16:53But, you know, look,
00:16:55when the,
00:16:55when money is handed over
00:16:56to the state,
00:16:56to the Commerce Department,
00:16:59that is, that goes
00:16:59into unclaimed funds.
00:17:02It's come from banks,
00:17:02insurance companies,
00:17:04you know, credit card
00:17:04companies, etc.,
00:17:07who have also already been
00:17:07searching for rightful owners.
00:17:12Through various means,
00:17:14for 5 to 10 years,
00:17:14sometimes even longer.
00:17:17And so by
00:17:18the time it gets to the state,
00:17:18it's already aged a bit.
00:17:22And what our proposal
00:17:22has a day after
00:17:25it has to sit in the state
00:17:25for ten years,
00:17:28before it becomes,
00:17:28subject to the shipment,
00:17:32which will be including now
00:17:32in the budget bill, language
00:17:35means that the property
00:17:35gets turned over to the state,
00:17:37and then we can tap into it
00:17:37to do whatever we want.
00:17:41Now, we are not trying
00:17:41to take money from Bill
00:17:44and Betty Buckeye, as the,
00:17:44commissioner or US county
00:17:48executive in Cuyahoga
00:17:48has claimed, because we have
00:17:51almost $300 million
00:17:51every year of new money
00:17:56that is coming into
00:17:56the unclaimed funds
00:17:58that will age ten years before
00:17:58we could, take access to it.
00:18:03And,
00:18:03and we have plenty of money
00:18:06available
00:18:06to meet the needs of anybody
00:18:08who has a valid claim
00:18:08as they come forward.
00:18:11The fact of the matter is in
00:18:11the commerce will verify this,
00:18:14that the the, potential
00:18:14for claims, valid claims
00:18:19to be made to draw against
00:18:19those dollars
00:18:22are generally very, very slim,
00:18:22especially after ten years
00:18:25or even longer.
00:18:27So we are not using taxpayer
00:18:27money.
00:18:30This is not tax money.
00:18:32This is these are assets
00:18:32that are unclaimed and
00:18:35unaccounted for in terms
00:18:37of having a relationship
00:18:37with their ultimate owners.
00:18:41We're also putting $1 million
00:18:41a year
00:18:43into the Commerce Department
00:18:43in their budget
00:18:45to help them
00:18:45do an even better job.
00:18:47They're already doing
00:18:47a lot of work to find the,
00:18:51the owners of this property.
00:18:53We want them to redouble
00:18:53their efforts further.
00:18:55Again,
00:18:56we want to make sure
00:18:56that anybody who makes a claim
00:18:58is is going to be satisfied.
00:19:00And we are very comfortable
00:19:00that that will happen.
00:19:02So the formula to fund
00:19:02public schools
00:19:04has triggered a lot of debate
00:19:04this budget cycle.
00:19:07Much of that has centered
00:19:08on decisions
00:19:08about the final phase
00:19:09of what proponents call
00:19:09the fair school funding plan.
00:19:12That was a 2021 reform effort
00:19:12by lawmakers to put money
00:19:15toward public schools
00:19:15based on the actual costs
00:19:18associated
00:19:18with educating a student.
00:19:20How does the Senate's version
00:19:21differ
00:19:21from what the House did with.
00:19:23Well, yeah,
00:19:24I think the governor's version
00:19:24and the Senate
00:19:26and the House's version
00:19:26are different than ours.
00:19:29We're all trying to
00:19:30get to the same place,
00:19:31some kind of a formula
00:19:31that makes sense, to fund our
00:19:34very important schools.
00:19:36We certainly believe in that.
00:19:37But the Senate's plan
00:19:37is really the true
00:19:40continuation
00:19:40of the fair school funding.
00:19:45Plan,
00:19:45in its final two year phase.
00:19:48So we've added dollars,
00:19:48we've added $634 million
00:19:51into that funding.
00:19:53We've also added parameters
00:19:53that we think are critical
00:19:56in terms of recognizing
00:19:58that there should be some
00:19:58premiums paid for performance,
00:20:02and also for,
00:20:02to account for enrollment
00:20:05changes,
00:20:05you know, school systems
00:20:07that are growing in
00:20:07enrollment,
00:20:09should be properly recognized
00:20:09for that in the formula
00:20:12schools.
00:20:13Many of our systems
00:20:13have seen steady declines
00:20:16in the number of students,
00:20:17and they shouldn't
00:20:17get the same amount of money,
00:20:19if they get fewer students
00:20:19to take care of.
00:20:21So, and in my,
00:20:21finance committee,
00:20:24we've been having hearings
00:20:24for the last couple of days,
00:20:26the number of student
00:20:26superintendents
00:20:29and school board members
00:20:29have come in to testify
00:20:31how much they like
00:20:31the funding formula that
00:20:34that we have put into place
00:20:34under our, our method.
00:20:38No school system will get less
00:20:38than they received
00:20:41in fiscal 21.
00:20:44Okay, so we've protected them
00:20:44with that flaw.
00:20:47In a lot of school systems
00:20:47are going to see increases.
00:20:50A few are going to see
00:20:50some decreases.
00:20:52But you either have a funding
00:20:52formula or you don't.
00:20:55If you put
00:20:55artificial guarantees in
00:20:57then you
00:20:57really don't have a formula.
00:21:00And then one of the
00:21:00biggest additions in the house
00:21:03was this
00:21:03addition of a ceiling, about
00:21:03how many cash reserve schools
00:21:07could hold on to.
00:21:08They said that at 30%,
00:21:08you guys raised it to 50.
00:21:12And you also added
00:21:12an overflow allowance.
00:21:14So tell me a little bit
00:21:14about the decision
00:21:16making behind
00:21:17one of the advantages
00:21:18of going
00:21:18last in the budget process
00:21:20after the governor
00:21:20in the Senate
00:21:21or the, in the House,
00:21:21is that we get we had more
00:21:24a little bit more time
00:21:24to go out and talk to people.
00:21:26So I went out and I met
00:21:26with superintendents.
00:21:28Many of them,
00:21:29talked with them
00:21:29on the phone,
00:21:31got a lot of feedback from
00:21:31school board members as well.
00:21:34You know,
00:21:34it was pretty clear early
00:21:34on that the 30% cap would be
00:21:37would be a problem. Okay.
00:21:39Because remember,
00:21:39we want our school systems
00:21:41to be fiscally responsible,
00:21:41and that means that you
00:21:44should have enough set aside
00:21:44as carryover
00:21:47from a prior year, in case
00:21:47you run into some emergency.
00:21:51So what we did
00:21:51was we raised it to 50%,
00:21:54to provide
00:21:54some accommodation for funds
00:21:58that needed to be kept
00:21:58on their books year over year.
00:22:01But we also wanted
00:22:01to make an allowance
00:22:03for capital projects
00:22:03that need to happen. Right.
00:22:05And so, so our, our,
00:22:08difference with the house
00:22:09is not only the amount,
00:22:09the rate from 30 to 50%,
00:22:13but we are adding we've added
00:22:13language that allows for,
00:22:16funds to be set aside,
00:22:16separate
00:22:18from their operating funds
00:22:18for capital projects
00:22:22that would be,
00:22:23conducted within three years
00:22:23of the time period
00:22:27that we
00:22:27we would start looking at this
00:22:28in this,
00:22:28this next fiscal year.
00:22:31And so we've had a lot of
00:22:31positive feedback about that.
00:22:33And so we think it's,
00:22:35we think our, our, our program
00:22:35is the right one to go with,
00:22:39we'll see how it goes in
00:22:40when we get to conference
00:22:40with, with the house.
00:22:43But, we feel that
00:22:43that's the right thing to do.
00:22:45And I think a lot of school
00:22:46systems are very happy
00:22:46with our approach.
00:22:49There are tens of millions of
00:22:50dollars
00:22:50worth of bonus royalties
00:22:52coming from the oil and gas
00:22:53drilling
00:22:53going on under Ohio state
00:22:55parks and public lands,
00:22:55according to budget documents.
00:22:58The Senate
00:22:58kind of shifted money around
00:23:00it, cut general tax revenue
00:23:00for Parks and recreation,
00:23:03and then fill that hole
00:23:03with those fracking dollars,
00:23:06one conservation
00:23:06advocate tells me.
00:23:08It's really hard to restore
00:23:10general revenue funding once
00:23:10it's cut in future budgets.
00:23:14And these fracking
00:23:14royalties are finite.
00:23:16So why not just release
00:23:16the bonus royalties to Odnr?
00:23:20Well, I would disagree
00:23:20with whoever that source
00:23:22was that that it's difficult
00:23:22to get things back in the GRF.
00:23:25We have a very robust process
00:23:25every two years,
00:23:28and we're
00:23:28we're in the thick of it right
00:23:28now, where justifications
00:23:32can be made for additions
00:23:32to GRF.
00:23:34We're doing it all the time.
00:23:34Okay.
00:23:36So I think that's a
00:23:36that's a false narrative.
00:23:38But in this case
00:23:38what we're taking is
00:23:40we're talking about it's
00:23:40moving
00:23:41the royalties generated
00:23:41from fracking on public lands,
00:23:45which are, by the way,
00:23:45our public lands.
00:23:47They don't belong to Odnr.
00:23:49They belong to the people
00:23:49of the state of Ohio.
00:23:51We're talking
00:23:51about direct redirect.
00:23:53Those those, royalties
00:23:53back to the general fund,
00:23:57but to the line that supports
00:23:57the operating costs of Odnr.
00:24:02So it's really not leaving
00:24:02Odnr.
00:24:04And so,
00:24:05it's just a
00:24:06it's a proper redirection
00:24:06that allows us to,
00:24:09to make up
00:24:09for some other cuts
00:24:11that we had to make
00:24:11in odd budget.
00:24:13It's simply it's accounting.
00:24:15And we're not going
00:24:16to deprive Odnr
00:24:17of their basic requirements
00:24:17to, to run their operation.
00:24:21We they do some great work,
00:24:23and we want to make sure
00:24:23that they continue to do so.
00:24:26The Senate is scheduled
00:24:26to make final changes
00:24:28to the budget
00:24:28this coming week,
00:24:29with a floor vote on either
00:24:29Wednesday or Thursday.
00:24:33That's it for this week
00:24:33for my colleagues
00:24:35at the statehouse News
00:24:35Bureau of Ohio Public Media.
00:24:38Thanks for watching.
00:24:39Please check out our website
00:24:39at State news.org
00:24:41or find us online by searching
00:24:41State of Ohio Show.
00:24:45Stay in the know
00:24:45by registering for Ohio
00:24:47State House
00:24:47alerts through this QR code,
00:24:49or by texting
00:24:49state news to (380)233-5686.
00:24:54You can also hear more
00:24:55from us on our podcast,
00:24:55The Ohio State House scoop.
00:24:58Look for it
00:24:58every Monday morning
00:25:00wherever
00:25:00you get your podcasts.
00:25:02And please join us next time
00:25:02for the State of Ohio. You.
00:26:06Support for the Statehouse
00:26:06News Bureau comes from
00:26:09Medical Mutual,
00:26:09dedicated to the health
00:26:11and well-being of Ohioans,
00:26:12offering health insurance
00:26:12plans, as well as dental,
00:26:15vision and wellness programs
00:26:15to help people
00:26:17achieve their goals
00:26:17and remain healthy.
00:26:19More at Med mutual.com.
00:26:21The law offices of Porter,
00:26:21right, Morris and Arthur LLP.
00:26:24Porter Wright is dedicated
00:26:24to bringing inspired legal
00:26:27outcomes to the Ohio business
00:26:27community.
00:26:30More at porterwright.com.
00:26:31Porter Wright
00:26:31inspired Every day
00:26:34in Ohio Education Association,
00:26:34representing 120,000
00:26:37educators who are united
00:26:37in their mission
00:26:39to create the excellent
00:26:39public schools.
00:26:41Every child
00:26:41deserves more at OHEA.org.
Note : Transcripts are compiled from uncorrected captions